People Bones

Owen is preoccupied with death lately. It’s disturbing. I don’t know if we unwittingly started it, but there it is. He always starts into the topic as though we’re finishing a previous conversation. It’s especially eerie, because it makes me feel as though he’s been pondering his own mortality since we last spoke on the subject. One afternoon this week on the way home from daycare, he opened the conversation like this:

“Is your grandpa people bones?”

I didn’t understand him at first. I don’t hear so well, especially in the car. After repeating himself a couple of times, he clarified: “People bones. You know, like dinosaur bones.”

Owen was afraid of the towering dinosaur skeletons we saw at the Natural History Museum until I reassured him that dinosaurs had all died long ago. In providing this reassurance, I seem to have opened another vast chasm of fear and uncertainty.

Both my grandfathers died before I was born, so I said that yes, I suppose, my grandpa is just bones now.

“But why do people turn into bones?”

“Well, because after you die you go into the ground and …” frantically, here, I try to think of how not to explain about worms and rotting and human flesh… “and eventually all that’s left is bones.”

(Last week, on the same subject, he tried to deny that he had bones. “But we don’t have bones, mummy! That’s silly.” I showed him that he did, under his skin.)

“But I don’t want to go in the ground! I don’t want to die! No-no-no-no! I WON’T!” He protested, in a three-year old’s tantrummy denial of the inevitable.

My heart quavered a little. “But you will, honey. Not for a very long time, but you will. Everybody dies.”

“Everybody? But I don’t WANT to die.” (and repeat).

I uttered some platitudes about how he won’t die until he’s very old. The problem is, whenever I start in on this subject, he invariably asks about the likelihood of death of people he knows who are old, like his great-grandmother or great-grand-aunt. The latter is completely bedridden and though Owen hugs and kisses her like a champion, he worries about growing old, and asks me whether his legs will one day stop working. Maybe.

Faced with his repetitive denial of his own mortality, I scrambled around thinking how other people might answer these questions. Religion! What do religious people tell their children? They reassure them with angels and spirits, not bones and earth. I said, “Some people think that when you die you go live with the angels up in the sky and that you meet all the people who died before.”

But either because I didn’t sound convinced or because this prospect was equally foreign, Owen protested again: “I don’t want to go live with the angels! I want to live with you!”

I reassured him, over and over again. Then I told him that no one had ever lived forever, but if he was really, really lucky, maybe he could do it. I said he would have to eat all his vegetables, and exercise really well, and be careful with his body (including not running outside the daycare, as he had done that morning). He latched onto this possibility, fiercely.

“I will do all those things what you said,” he said. “Then I won’t die.”

As you can imagine, the conversation went around and around from there, spiralling far out of my control. I have heard of the cosmic conversations we can have with small children, but this was my first taste of it. I felt utterly out of my depth.

My instincts are telling me to speak the truth about death no matter how much it hurts but, simultaneously, I want to protect my child from this knowledge as I would try to protect him from the thing itself.

4 comments on “People Bones

  1. I agree with you, Anna. Truth. Small doses of truth, as needed. Your post reminds me of Rosencrantz& Guildenstern Are Dead when Guildenstern marvels about how we must all be born with an intuition of mortality. He says something to the effect that “there must have been a moment when we realized that we don’t go on forever… and yet, I can’t remember it, can you?” It’s weird to think that this all feels so catastrophic and sensitive, and yet Owen will just somehow absorb it all into the flows of his normal life.

  2. Jane Cowie on said:

    Hello there. Just read this post and remember my own fear as a child.
    I have the book ” Freddie the Leaf” and will send it.I bought this when Jim’s fahter died and Eliz was about 6 years. We were of course dealing with a very real loss with lots of questions.
    It is a very gentle story addressing death/dying for a child and helps to make it less scary.
    Written by Leo Buscaglia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leo_Buscaglia
    This is the u-tube version- four parts:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A0ZI-Rf1_sk
    Hope htis is useful
    JEC

  3. Jane Cowie on said:

    These are the other links, although when I watched, they came up automatically.
    It is beautifully done, however may be a little too sophisticated for 3 years.

    2) http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=Q1Z8BLRMLjc&feature=endscreen
    3) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVnwrSL8id0&feature=relmfu
    4) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BvwD1rSz63E&feature=relmfu

  4. Jane Cowie on said:

    Another lovely video:
    Lifetimes- about 9 minutes with very tasteful illustrations and sensitive explanations.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwwGBVa1j9A

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

HTML tags are not allowed.